Compared honestly
Elfster vs DrawNames vs Gift List Keeper
Three free ways to run a Secret Santa or Kris Kringle. We make Gift List Keeper, so here is a fair look at all three, including where the others do better. Checked October 2026.
| Feature | Gift List Keeper | DrawNames | Elfster |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free to use | |||
| Account needed to take part | No account or email | No account (email on web) | Yes, everyone signs up |
| Keep couples apart | |||
| Set a dollar limit | |||
| Wish lists | Free wish list to share | ||
| Phone app | Works in your phone's browser | ||
| Made for Australia (AUD, Kris Kringle) | |||
| Shared family gift list with budgets | |||
| Ads | Yes, small ads keep it free | No ads | Free, see their site |
Pick Gift List Keeper if…
you want nobody to sign up or give an email, you call it Kris Kringle, or you also want one shared family gift list so nobody doubles up.
Pick DrawNames if…
you want no ads at all and a phone app, and your group is happy to give an email address.
Pick Elfster if…
your group will all make accounts and you want extras like anonymous questions and a full app.
Questions people ask
What is the best free Secret Santa app in Australia?
It depends on your group. Gift List Keeper needs no account or email and is built for Australian Kris Kringle. DrawNames has no ads and a phone app. Elfster has the most features, but everyone signs up.
Which Secret Santa generator doesn't need an account?
Gift List Keeper and DrawNames both let people take part without creating an account. On Gift List Keeper, people don't need an email address either: each person opens their own private link.
Can I stop couples drawing each other?
Yes. All three tools let you set people who can't draw each other, such as partners.